Condiment Recipes

Prepared condiments are usually full of additives, corn syrup, and chemicals. Make your own fresh for better health and better taste too!

Sort By: Name | Highest Rated | Newest

Pickled Asparagus
Mom started me canning at a very early age. This recipe quickly became a personal favorite, not only for me but for a group of yo…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Turmeric,
- Mustard Seed, Yellow,
- Dill Seed
Herb Cream Cheese
I had a recipe that called for "garlic and herb cream cheese" - like Rondele? - but I didn't have any, so I checked out my Spice …
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Chip Dip Seasoning
Lois' Best Dressing and Marinade
I found a recipe in a church ladies cookbook. I needed to decipher it and change it to my liking. I needed a Qty. of dressing as…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Pepper, Ground,
- Salt, Kosher,
- Basil, California Sweet,
- Parsley,
- Mustard Powder, Mild
Sweet & Spicy BBQ Sauce
This was an experiment. Since I am writing a cookbook, my husband always says, OH. that was delicious what did you put in it? I c…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Chile Peppers, Habanero,
- Hickory Smoke Salt,
- Mustard Powder, Regular,
- Onion Pieces
Tomato Herb Vinaigrette
This recipe was developed because my family really likes Italian dressing and French dressing. I was tired of buying bottled dres…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Celery Seed,
- Salt, Kosher,
- Thyme, Mediterranean,
- Oregano, Mexican,
- Pepper, Ground,
- Mustard Powder, Regular,
- Onion Pieces,
- Garlic Powder,
- Tomato Powder,
- Basil, California Sweet
Spicy Apple Bagel Spread
I love cream cheese on a toasted bagel. This is a decadent version. Perfect for Brunch Buffets . …
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Cake Spice
Winter Salsa
I made this up one evening when I ran out of jar salsa. My son liked it so well that I rarely use jar salsa now.…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Cinnamon, Ceylon,
- Chili Con Carne Seasoning
Basic Mustard Recipe
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Mustard Powder, Regular
Chipotle Mustard
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Garlic Powder,
- Horseradish Powder,
- Sunny Paris Seasoning,
- Paprika, Smoked Hot,
- Chipotle Powder,
- Ukrainian Village Spice
Coarse Mustard
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Horseradish Powder,
- Onion Powder,
- Garlic Powder,
- Mustard Seed, Crushed
Ginger Curry Mustard
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Garlic Powder,
- Onion Powder,
- Pepper, Ground,
- Ginger,
- Curry Powder, Sweet
Passion Fruit Wasabi Mustard
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Garlic Powder,
- Onion Powder,
- Turmeric,
- Wasabi,
- Mustard Powder, Regular
Sweet Onion Bell Pepper Mustard
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Ukrainian Village Spice,
- Onion Pieces,
- Bell Peppers
Tarragon Peppercorn Mustard
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Garlic Powder,
- Onion Powder,
- Tarragon
Indian Spiced Yogurt Dressing
First place winner at the Wisconsin State Fair, 2011
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Cayenne Pepper,
- Turmeric,
- Ginger,
- Coriander,
- Cumin
Parmesan Tri-Peppercorn Salad Dressing or Dip
2nd Place winner at the Wisconsin State Fair, 2011
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Celery Seed,
- Pepper, Ground,
- Pepper-Lemon Seasoning,
- Black and Red Spice
Spicy and Sweet Salad Dressing
3rd place winner at the Wisconsin State Fair, 2011
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Cayenne Pepper,
- Oregano, Greek,
- Paprika, Half-Sharp
Asian Guacamole
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Sesame Seeds,
- Wasabi
Pizzazz Spread
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Chicago Deep Dish Pizza,
- Taylor St Cheese Sprinkle
Cocktail Sauce
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Bronzeville Rib Rub
Salsa Blanca Slaw (for Fish Tacos)
We love fish tacos, and I created this slaw using all spices from the Spice House.
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Onion Powder,
- Chipotle Powder,
- Coriander,
- Adobo Seasoning,
- Cumin,
- Oregano, Greek,
- Garlic Powder
Black Garlic Dip
Add a dash of the Vulcan's Fire salt to give it a great kick!
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Chives,
- Black Garlic,
- Horseradish Powder
Black Garlic Vinaigrette
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Pomegranate Molasses,
- Black Garlic
Grilled Peach and Lingonberry Salsa
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Ginger, Crystallized,
- Jamaican Jerk Seasoning
Vinegar Allergy Italian Salad Dressing
My own creation born out of desperation when I discovered vinegar was causing me to get Migraine headaches. Your Sumac has open…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Sumac,
- Italian Dressing Mix,
- Shallots,
- Pepper, Ground,
- Marjoram,
- Garlic Powder,
- Basil, California Sweet,
- Parsley
Cranberry Zinfandel Port Relish
It’s beginning to rain and that weather keeps me inside and cooking. I began to research and work on old holiday recipes. I thou…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Allspice,
- Cloves
onion dill dip
Personal favorite, can be used with all fresh vegetables and potato chips, everyone enjoys this dip and it goes a long way.…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Dill,
- English Prime Rib Rub,
- Onion Pieces
Italian Salad Dressing
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Italian Herbs,
- Italian Dressing Mix
Greek Salad Dressing
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Greektown Seasoning
Chinese Five Spice Dipping Sauce
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Chinese Five Spice
Lavender Vinaigrette
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Thyme, Mediterranean,
- Mustard Powder, Regular,
- Sea Salt, La Baleine,
- Lavender,
- Lemon Peel,
- Shallots
Rosewater Syrup
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Rose Water,
- Cinnamon, Ceylon
Horseradish Cheese Spread
During our family visits to my parents' Door County home, we discovered a horseradish cheese spread that wasn't available in the C…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Horseradish Powder
Pullman BBQ Sauce
I just wanted to make a BBQ sauce to go with my ribs . I was tired of all the overly sweet & gloppy, high fructose corn syrup con…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Chili Con Carne Seasoning,
- Historic Pullman Pork Chop Seasoning
Harisa/Harissa
This personal favorite has replaced salsa and ketchup. It flavors rices, pasta sauces, even substitutes for mayonnaise on a sandw…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Cumin,
- Caraway,
- Coriander,
- Sea Salt, La Baleine,
- Chile de Arbol Peppers
CRANBERRY JEWEL RELISH
This is my mother-in-law's recipe. I am not sure where it came from but was always a family favorite.…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Ginger, Crystallized
Cassia Bud Sweet Pickles
This is a family favorite. Very easy. Doesn't require the days of soaking like other Cassia Bud Pickle recipes do.…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Cassia Buds,
- Celery Seed,
- Mustard Seed, Yellow,
- Salt, Kosher
Surprising Salsa
When I served this, someone complained it wasn't hot enough. The heat hit her a couple of seconds later and she gasped for air. He…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Cayenne Pepper
Orange Cranberry Compote
I developed this recipe which is based on basic homemade cranberry sauce. The orange flower water is the secret ingredient, adding…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Orange Flower Water
Sun-Dried Tomato Sauce
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Italian Herbs,
- Fennel
Trinidad Garlic Lemon marinade
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Trinidad Lemon-Garlic Mix
Walnut Orange Chutney
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Mace,
- Ginger, Crystallized,
- Orange Peel
Quebec Beef Spice Marinade
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Quebec Beef Spice
Cucumber Sauce
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Spearmint,
- Chip Dip Seasoning
Fig Chutney
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Organic Sea Salt,
- Cardamom, Green,
- Anise,
- Ginger, Crystallized
Hot Caramel Cinnamon Sauce
This is a spectacular recipe. It takes only moments to make and my family absolutely loves it. Everytime I tell someone about it…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Vanilla Extract,
- Cinnamon, Vietnamese
Plum Ginger Mustard
This recipe was created by Spice House staffers Adam Schwartz and Tracy Turoczy for an event at the Evanston Women's Club.…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Ginger,
- Mustard Powder, Hot
6x4 H.A.C.A Hot Sauce
This recipe was part of an experiment to answer the question: “Can a good hot sauce be made from powdered ingredients?”. The a…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Cloves,
- Bay Leaves, California,
- Vulcan's Fire Salt,
- Curry Powder, Sweet,
- Paprika, California,
- Chile Peppers, Habanero,
- Chipotle Powder,
- Chile Peppers, Ancho,
- Chile Peppers, Jalapeno,
- Cayenne Pepper,
- Garlic Powder,
- Onion Powder
Green Goddess Dressing - light and healthy
I saw a similar recipe and decided to blend 3 or 4 green goddess dressings with my ideas. Spice House French Leaf Tarragon is real…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Tarragon
Gateway to the North BBQ sauce
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Chipotle Powder,
- Cayenne Pepper,
- Allspice,
- Gateway To The North Maple Garlic Seasoning
Cherry Chipotle BBQ Sauce
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Thyme, Mediterranean,
- Cumin,
- Chipotle in Adobo
Apple and Dried Fruit Chutney
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Sea Salt, La Baleine,
- Allspice,
- Coriander,
- Ginger,
- Mace,
- Cinnamon, Vietnamese,
- Lemon Peel
Vulcan's Fire Dip
This dip is delicious right away, but better if you leave it in the fridge overnight to give the flavors time to blend.…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Vulcan's Fire Salt,
- Aleppo Pepper
Panch Phoron
The ingredients listed make a standard Bengali Five-Spice, but many cooks have their own recipe for this mixture. Sometimes celer…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Charnushka,
- Fenugreek Seeds,
- Mustard Seed, Yellow,
- Fennel,
- Cumin
Chipotle Lime Mayonnaise
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Cilantro
Guacamole
I created this "enhanced" guacamole recipe a year ago. It's the best I've tasted.
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- California Pepper Blend,
- Pilsen Latino Seasoning,
- Salt, Kosher
Toasted Fennel Spice Rub
Made it up from other ideas. I like to make a spice mix to my own specifications without too much salt or none at all. Then add i…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Garlic Powder,
- Cinnamon, Ceylon,
- Chile Peppers, New Mexican,
- Peppercorns, Tellicherry,
- Coriander,
- Fennel
Chocolate Salad Dressing
I invented this right after we started carrying Chocolate Extract, while looking for new ways to use it. It's one of my favorite …
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Chocolate Extract
Jamaican Jerk Marinade
This is a slightly tweaked version of The Spice House's traditional jerk marinade recipe, submitted by long-time crew member Jenni…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Jamaican Jerk Seasoning
Dad's Steak Seasoning
This recipe is a slight variation on what my Dad used, during the years I was growing up, to season steaks on the barbecue. I con…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Mustard Powder, Mild,
- Curry Powder, Sweet,
- Garlic Powder,
- Pepper, Ground
Sun Fish Marinade
I love fresh tuna and fresh salmon on the grill. This is a simple Marinade, but oh... the flavor is to die for. The main Recipe d…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Sunny Singapore
Berbere - Ethiopian Spice Paste
Having served as a foster parent for a number of Ethiopian young people during the 90's, I was lucky enough to get this recipe. I…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Pepper, Ground,
- Cayenne Pepper,
- Paprika, Half-Sharp,
- Allspice,
- Cinnamon, Vietnamese,
- Cloves,
- Nutmeg,
- Fenugreek Seeds,
- Coriander,
- Cardamom, Green,
- Ginger
Berbere - Ethiopian spice blend
The non-specific amounts in this recipe are because each Ethiopian cook has her own variation of this basic spice blend. Feel fre…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Garlic Powder,
- Onion Powder,
- Cardamom, Green,
- Allspice,
- Cinnamon, Ceylon,
- Curry Powder, Maharajah Style,
- Anise,
- Garam Masala,
- Cumin,
- Ginger,
- Paprika, Half-Sharp
No Cook Peanut Sauce
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Ginger,
- Crushed Red Pepper,
- Garlic Powder
Niter Kibbeh
Although this recipe is basic to Ethiopian cooking, it tastes wonderful on many things: steamed vegetables, mashed potatoes, steam…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Nutmeg,
- Cloves,
- Cinnamon Sticks,
- Cardamom, Green,
- Turmeric
Grill Seasoning My Way
I love the smoky flavor of hot smoked Spanish paprika from The Spice House - it's the best! I wanted a grill seasoning that could…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Chipotle Powder,
- Cajun Seasonings,
- Paprika, Smoked Sweet,
- Garlic Powder,
- Onion Powder
Virgin Islands Spiced Salt
This recipe comes to us courtesy of Jill Norman's fabulous spice book, "Herbs and Spices: The Cook's Reference." It's the best b…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Thyme, Lemon,
- Nutmeg,
- Cloves,
- Peppercorns, Tellicherry,
- Sea Salt, Maldon
Salt Free Southwest Seasoning Blend
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Adobo Seasoning,
- Cumin,
- Oregano, Greek,
- Onion Powder,
- Garlic Powder,
- Coriander,
- Cayenne Pepper,
- Paprika, Smoked Sweet,
- Chipotle Powder,
- Pepper, Ground,
- Chili Powder,
- Chile Peppers, Pasilla
Salt Free Cajun Seasoning Blend
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Bay Leaves, Turkish,
- Thyme, Mediterranean,
- Paprika, California,
- Sage,
- Oregano, Greek,
- Onion Powder,
- Chile Peppers, Pasilla,
- Chile Peppers, New Mexican,
- Garlic Powder,
- Chipotle Powder,
- Cayenne Pepper,
- Pepper, Ground
Sesame Sumac Pesto
This Middle-Eastern version of pesto is quick to whip up.
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Tahini,
- Pepper, Ground,
- Garlic Powder,
- Sesame Seeds,
- Oregano, Greek,
- Thyme, Mediterranean,
- Thyme, Lemon,
- Sumac
Mad Annie's Turkey Basting Stuff
In another of my MAD scientific kitchen experiments, I wanted to create the ULTIMATE turkey. Without much research, I found the s…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Thyme, Lemon,
- Cardamom, Green,
- Sunny Spain Seasoning,
- Paprika, Hungarian Sweet ,
- Pepper, Ground,
- Celery Salt,
- Nutmeg,
- Coriander,
- Rosemary,
- Sage
Sherry Apple Juice Vinaigrette
I love vinaigrettes and make all kinds. This is one I made up that I love.
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Herbes De Provence
Those Onions!
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Thyme, French,
- Demi-Glace Duck Sauce
Ginger Dessert Sauce
This sauce was used in the dessert plate, to compliment Japanese Green Tea Cakes and Star Anise Ice Cream for our "Stir It Up in C…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Vanilla Extract,
- Coriander,
- Lemon Peel
Picco de Gallo
This recipe was submitted by an anonymous customer from Alabama. He said he'd originally gotten this recipe from a neighbor who i…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Adobo Seasoning,
- Pepper, Ground,
- Organic Sea Salt, Coarse,
- Chile Peppers, Habanero
Simple Mango Salsa
This recipe comes from "A Cook's Guide to Chicago," by Marilyn Pocious. This salsa was served at her booksigning event in the Old…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Onion Pieces,
- Chile Peppers, Jalapeno
Baba Ghanoush
This smokey eggplant dip is a great appetizer for any type of Middle Eastern meal.
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Aleppo Pepper,
- Paprika, Smoked Hot,
- Tahini
Star Anise Cherry Reduction
This recipe was seen in the New York Daily News, May 10, 2005 in a piece featuring Star Anise. "This sauce is delicious served …
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Star Anise, Hand-Select,
- Peppercorns, Tellicherry
Hummus
This is a quick recipe that can be thrown together in minutes. I try to keep a couple cans of chickpeas (also called garbanzo bea…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Sumac,
- Cumin
Orange-Chipotle Oil
This recipe was adapted from Jim Tarantino's book, "Marinades: Dry Rubs, Pastes & Marinades for Poultry, Meat, Seafood, Cheese & …
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Orange Peel,
- Chile Peppers, Brown Chipotle
Orange-Chipotle Marinaded Flank Steak with Ancho Chile Sauce
This recipe was adapted from Jim Tarantino's book, "Marinades: Dry Rubs, Pastes & Marinades for Poultry, Meat, Seafood, Cheese & …
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Demi-Glace,
- Tomato Powder,
- Cinnamon Sticks,
- Shallots,
- Chile Peppers, Ancho,
- Chipotle in Adobo
Plum Good Sauce
This recipe comes to us courtesy of the "Spice of Life Cookbook" by Treva Davis (no longer in print).…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Ginger,
- Nutmeg,
- Cloves
Wasabi and Green Apple Sauce
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Wasabi
Green Peppercorn Sauce
This recipe was provided by Jeanne Hicks. She shared several recipes with us at our Evanston store. She also provided a recipe f…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Peppercorns, Green
Chile Oil
I use this with my "Pasta Toss" recipe which is also listed on The Spice House website.
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Crushed Red Pepper
Salsa Verde con Chiles de Arbol
My family knows these chiles as "chile de arbol." This is a fast, easy salsa to make and it's very authentic. It is always a crowd…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Chile de Arbol Peppers
Annatto Paste
This recipe ortesy Emeril Lagasse, 2001
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Cumin,
- Oregano, Greek,
- Annato Seed
Super Simple Spice House Pesto
Sometimes we enjoy taking The Spice House out to farmer's markets and food festival events. The occasion usually calls for the ven…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Pesto Pasta Seasoning
Pink Peppercorn Butter
I've always loved indulging in steak at restaurants. It's usually served with a big dollop of butter. For very special occasions…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Peppercorns, Pink,
- Tarragon
Peanut Marinade for Meat
I got this recipe from my neighbor's fiance, who is from Sierra Leone. I have tried this on beef, chicken, and pork, and all were …
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Thyme, Lemon
Dry Rub for Pork and Salmon
This recipe makes a large amount of dry rub. I worked on it for a year--adding and subtracting--and finally got it to this delici…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Oregano, Greek,
- Celery Seed,
- Garlic Powder,
- Onion Powder,
- Cayenne Pepper,
- Chile Peppers, Ancho,
- Cumin,
- Paprika, Smoked Hot,
- Paprika, Hungarian Sweet
Recado Rojo (Red Achiote Paste)
This recipe comes to us courtesy of Jill Norman's fabulous spice book, "Herbs and Spices: The Cook's Reference." It's the best b…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Oregano, Greek,
- Cloves,
- Cumin,
- Peppercorns, Tellicherry,
- Coriander,
- Annato Seed
Ice Box Pickles
This family recipe is compliments of my grandmother, Jeanette Kesselring, from Arnold, Missouri. These are delicious eaten straig…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Celery Seed
Mango Salsa
This salsa is a great compliment to fish dishes, like "Sea Bass Crusted with Moroccan Spices" I also listed on The Spice House web…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
Herbs de Provence Infused Oil
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Herbes De Provence,
- Pepper, Ground
Pesto
This recipe comes from our good friends Judith Dunbar Hines and Rick Delby at World Kitchen, a culinary program that takes place a…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
The Second Zippy Red Dressing
This recipe comes to us courtesy of the "Spice of Life Cookbook" by Treva Davis (no longer in print).…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Mustard Powder, Mild,
- Paprika, Hungarian Sweet ,
- Tomato Powder,
- Onion Powder
Creamy Garlic Dressing
This recipe comes to us courtesy of the "Spice of Life Cookbook" by Treva Davis (no longer in print).…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Paprika, Hungarian Sweet ,
- Chives,
- Garlic Powder,
- Onion Powder
Syrian Za'atar
My brother is the best cook in the family, and used to travel on business. After his supply of Za'atar (he got on his travels) ra…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Paprika, Hungarian Sweet ,
- Cumin,
- Thyme, Mediterranean,
- Sumac
Roasted-Garlic Puree
This recipe comes to us courtesy of Jimmy Bannos and John DeMers from their book, "The Heaven on Seven cookbook. Where it's Mardi…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
Pico De Gallo Salsa
This recipe comes to us courtesy of Jimmy Bannos and John DeMers from their book, "The Heaven on Seven cookbook. Where it's Marti…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
Incredible Seasoning Salt
This recipe was found in a cooking magazine by my Father back in the mid 1970's.
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Mustard Powder, Regular,
- Curry Powder, Maharajah Style,
- Mace,
- Monosodium Glutamate MSG,
- Pepper, Ground,
- Paprika, Hungarian Sweet ,
- Garlic Salt, Regular or Fancy,
- Celery Salt,
- Onion Salt,
- Dill Seed,
- Sea Salt, La Baleine
Spike's Raspberry Dill Vinaigrette with Persephone's Home Coming Salad
A very good friend of mine (Adam "Spike" Schoenwald, cause he deserves credit for this one) brought me a bottle of raspberry vineg…
Average Rating:
Spices Featured:
- Dill,
- Pepper, Ground,
- Sunny Spain Seasoning,
- Celery Salt

Condiment Recipes

Alphabetical

Category

Popular Spices

Seasonal

Seasonal Spices

Cuisine

Popular Spices

Gift Boxes and Accessories

Course

Popular Spices

Highest Rated

Cuisine

Popular Spices

Added to Cart:

	@ =
Total: $