Hermit Cookies Recipe

Average Rating:

Categories: American, Cookie, Dessert, Grain, Snack

Submitted By: Dorothy from Worcester.

Hermit Cookies Notes

I'm from New York City, so the only kind of hermit I knew was a reclusive woman to whom we brought food, books and other things when I was a kid. The Hermit Cookie, however, is a New England specialty. I have no idea where the name comes from unless it's from the Hermit Crab. Perhaps, it comes from the somewhat reserved, really it's more like shy, nature of many New Englanders. They just don't like to interfere. Anyway, Hermit Cookies are fragrant with spices. I found them a bit overwhelming, so I toned mine down and changed some of the ingredients. The idea of a delicious Hermit is to make it truly your own according to your taste preferences. Add your spices, tack on your family name, and you've got an instant family tradition!

Serves / Yields

About 10 Dozen Small Cookies

Preparation Instructions
  1. Sift together all of the dry ingredients and spices.

  2. In a mixing bowl, cream butter and sugar until smooth.

  3. Beat the eggs lightly first, then add the eggs to the butter and sugar. Mix well.

  4. Add molasses. Mix.

  5. Add milk. Mix.

  6. Add dry ingredients. Mix

  7. By hand, stir in raisins and powdered pure vanilla powder.

  8. Form dough into a ball. Wrap tightly in plastic wrap. Refrigerate for 2 hours.

  9. Preheat the oven to 350 degrees. If your oven runs hot, turn it down to 325 degrees.

  10. Lightly flour a board. Cut dough in half. Roll out one half of the dough into a sheet about 1/8 inch thick. Cut into whatever shapes you prefer. Most people make them into small rounds. Keep other half of dough refrigerated while working on the first batch.

  11. Place on non-stick cookie sheet or thoroughly greased cookie sheet. Bake for about 10 minutes. Cool on a rack.

Helpful Hints

Traditional Hermits can be made with molasses or without. The non-molasses version contains a heafty amount of just two spices: 1 teaspon each of cloves and nutmeg. It also uses 1 teaspoon of baking soda instead of baking powder. You'd add 3 eggs instead of 2 eggs. And, you'd need 3 cups of flour and 1 cup of butter. You'd need 1 1/2 cups of sugar without the molasses. Raisins would be the same.

Hermits do not usually contain mace or cardamom. I put them in because I like the taste. A Hermit can be any type of spice mix you enjoy. The Spice House has a wide variety of fresh spices. The quality of the spices really determine the quality of the cookie. Make your Hermits to your tastes!

Do not use baking powder with alum, as it will affect the taste of the cookies.

Quick Shopping List

Cloves, Whole or Ground
Ground, in a glass jar
1/2 cup jar, net wt. 2 oz.
Ceylon "True" Cinnamon, Whole or Ground
Ground, in a glass shaker jar
1/2 cup shaker jar, net wt. 2 oz.
Vietnamese "Saigon" Cassia Cinnamon, Cracked or Ground
Ground, in a glass shaker jar
1/2 cup in shaker jar, net 2 oz.
Nutmeg, Whole Or Ground
Whole, in a resealable bag
Mace, Whole Blade Or Ground
Ground, in a glass shaker jar
In a 1/2 cup shaker jar, net wt. 2 oz.
Green Cardamom, Whole Fancy Pods, Inner Seeds or Ground
Ground, in a glass shaker jar
1/2 cup shaker jar, net wt. 2 oz.
Madagascar Vanilla Powder
Very Fine Powder, in a glass jar
In a 1/2 cup shaker jar, net wt. 2.5 ounces

Submit Comment

Julia D. Said:

Pat L. are you sure you only put in 2 TABLESPOONS of milk? If anythign I had to add a bit of moisture (added some applesauce actually) to make it bind, not add more flour.

Make it Again? Julia D. would make this recipe again.

Gary R. Said:

As I understand it, the name comes from the need to store the cookies for a short time in the pantry to soften, before they are eaten. This time of hidden isolation led to their name of hermit.

Make it Again? Gary R. would make this recipe again.

Pat L. Said:

I followed this recipe to the letter and it came out way too loose to be considered a dough. I needed to add 1 1/2 cps of flour to tighten it up to even come close to a loose dough mixture. I just hope the taste is better than the ratio of liquid to dry ingredients.

Make it Again? Pat L. would not make this recipe again.

Michael B. Said:

I have been looking for a different kind of hermit cookie with mollasses & this one is it. The fact that this recipe has cardamom in it surprises me & I will be trying it because its exotic & fragrant. As the auther of this recipes dictates, to make it your own, makes this recipe my favourite now because it starts with a good base. I love mixed citrus peel so that is what I will add also to see what I get. I give this recipe a rating of 7 till I make them. thanks dorothy

Make it Again? Michael B. would make this recipe again.