The 7 Best Paprika Substitutes

Paprika is a vibrant spice that can have earthy, sweet, smokey and fiery flavor depending on the variety used. The bright hue is due to high levels of carotene found in Paprika, the same pigment found most notably in...carrots! Paprika is a key spice ingredient in stuffed bell peppers, deviled eggs, chorizo, and traditional Spanish rice. There are many varieties of paprika, and they are best recognized by their differing flavor, color, heat level, and smokiness. Read our paprika spice spotlight for more information on the nuanced differences between our paprikas.  

Want to have fresh, small batch Parika on hand for next time? Order Paprika today and have it delivered directly to your door.

Substitutes for Smoked Paprika 

Smoked paprika adds such a deep unforgettable flavor, that it can be hard to know what can replace paprika when you’re all out. Luckily, there are many different spices that will give you the same impact in your favorite dish. Our favorite smoky substitutions are:

• Chipotle chili powder (For smoked sweet paprikas)
• Cayenne pepper powder (For hot/sharp paprikas)
• Ancho pepper powder (For sweet paprikas)
• Guajillo Pepper powder (For hot/sharp paprikas)
• Chili powder (For hot/sharp paprikas)

ADD SMOKED PAPRIKA TO CART

Substitute for Hot Smoked Paprika

To create the same flavor as smoked paprika using the suggestions above will be your best bet. But if you want to add some heat that can be found in hot smoked paprika, use any of the substitutes above paired with hot red pepper flakes.

ADD HOT SMOKED PAPRIKA TO CART

Substitutes for Sweet Paprika: 

While smoked paprika gives a dish depth, sweet paprika is a classic staple and can be used in almost every dish alongside garlic and onion. Use the following spices instead to get the paprika flavor when you don’t have any on hand.

• Mild chili powder
• Tomato Powder

ADD HUNGARIAN SWEET PAPRIKA TO CART

Common Paprika Questions

Where is Paprika Most Commonly Used?

Paprika can be used in any dish to add a bright vibrant color, like in this Grilled Eggplant Recipe or Creamy Garlic Dressing. Smoked paprika is used to add a smoky aroma that’s desired in chorizo, sausages, or in these Lamb Kabobs.

Where Does Paprika Come From?